Series vs. Parallel Surround Speaker Wiring

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Hong Sung Hyeok
    Film Handler
    • Dec 2020
    • 61
    • Seoul, South KOREA

    #1

    Series vs. Parallel Surround Speaker Wiring

    Since I started managing cinema equipment, one question has remained unresolved: "What is the best way to wire surround speakers?"

    There are so many variables—such as the combined power output of amplifiers and speakers, composite impedance, the specific theater specifications, the budget, the equipment vendor, and the installer—that the results seem to vary wildly.

    Every senior I’ve spoken to has given me a different answer.
    So, I decided to create a tool myself using ChatGPT, relying heavily on QSC’s technical documentation.

    I don't know a thing about programming, but by constantly pestering the AI ​with requests,
    I poured a lot of time and tokens into it based solely on my own idea. Haha.
    If I had a knack for programming or web design, I could have made it even better, but I suppose this is the limit of my abilities.
    Amazingly, the whole thing ended up as a single 500KB HTML file.

    I feel confident enough now to share it publicly and ask for your opinions.
    The only issue is that I can't be 100% certain if the series/parallel wiring methods and analysis presented in the document are entirely correct.

    The results vary drastically depending on the combination of amplifiers and speakers—specifically the models, the quantity, and the wiring configuration used. Is there no single "right" answer?

    I’d appreciate it if you could check out the document I created and let me know what you think.
    It would also be great if you could suggest any additional amplifier or speaker models to include.​
    Attached Files
  • Steve Guttag
    Film God
    • Jan 2020
    • 3825
    • Annapolis, MD

    #2
    In general, you only want parallel connections. Series connections kill damping factor and will artificially cause boominess as the woofer isn't properly controlled. Certainly, in surround wiring, there comes times when series can allow an acceptable solution. For instance, if you have 6-surrounds on a side...you wire 3 in parallel (8/3 = 2.67Ω) and wire another 3 in parallel and then you series the two groups for an amplifier load of 5.33Ω. Each speaker sees a 2.67Ω resistance. While not ideal, it is better than having 8Ω. This method also prevents a single speaker failure from killing the whole string. Note, it would be horrible to do the opposite...three speakers in series for 24Ω and then parallel the two groups for 12Ω. While the amplifier will have no problem with the load, it might have problems with the voltage needed to reach the level but each speaker has a 24Ω resistor in its path making for no damping factor. If any speaker fails, two others go off line as a consequence too.

    I've been asking for 16Ω surround speakers. In particular, I've asked QSC and now MIT to come out with an SR-1090 (10" coax) with a 16Ω impedance for standard 5.1 and 7.1 theatres. Most amplifiers would handle up to 8 of them in parallel for a 2Ω load. That would cover a LOT of ground for most theatres. I asked Dolby the same thing for their DSR-1090 (though theirs existed prior to my request for a 16Ω surround. I don't know why when people make stuff for our industry that they don't consider its application a bit more. 16Ω on a surround speaker makes a lot of sense to me.

    Comment

    • Marco Giustini
      Film God
      • Jan 2020
      • 1191
      • Reading, UK

      #3
      Steve,

      Indeed about the 16ohm models. Do you think there is a technical reason preventing them from making them?

      On the series parallel, if I remember right, older linear amplifiers could barely deal with 4 ohm so some sort of series/parallel was necessary.
      some modern ones can easily deal with 2 ohm or even less so the issue has somewhat reduced.

      Comment

      • Steve Guttag
        Film God
        • Jan 2020
        • 3825
        • Annapolis, MD

        #4
        Most any amplifier deals with 4Ω...even tube amps often had 4Ω tap. Most modern amplifiers (within the past 30+ years deal with 2Ω.

        I think that 8Ω is more common so it is easier to source parts. QSC at least got that they should use different impedance drivers based on the use-case. Their ATMOS targeted surrounds are 4Ω. Their triple 15 LF cabinet (LF-4315) used 16Ω drivers for 16/3 = 5.33Ω.

        I've even asked QSC (and now MIT) to make the MHV-1090 (as used on the SC-424) in 16Ω to lower the noise. There is no good advantage to an 8Ω impedance there either.
        Last edited by Steve Guttag; 10-12-2026, 07:51 AM.

        Comment

        • Dave Macaulay
          Pro Film Handler
          • Jan 2020
          • 464
          • Toronto, Ontario, Canada

          #5
          For the reasons Steve gave, we avoid any series connections. Amplifiers are cheap, adding a channel to keep them all parallel is worth it.

          Comment

          • Marco Giustini
            Film God
            • Jan 2020
            • 1191
            • Reading, UK

            #6
            @Hong Sung Hyeok

            The sheet is quite nice - it's impressive what AI can do with HTML these days.

            I didn't look into that too carefully but some time ago (before AI existed!) I did my own excel sheet to calculate 7.1 power calculation. Dolby then added the same feature on their Atmos calculator so I stopped updating mine.

            Considering the Atmos calculator is quite a powerful tool and also contains 5.1 and 7.1, I wonder whether that should be the one to use? Keeping track of all the speaker data is not easy and I'd imagine Dolby are in a better position to get accurate data from the manufacturers.

            I'm not saying your hard work is not useful, just that the some of the features seem to be already available on the Dolby one. Thoughts?

            Comment

            • Steve Guttag
              Film God
              • Jan 2020
              • 3825
              • Annapolis, MD

              #7
              DARDT is a mix, for me. Their power estimates are very conservative and for 7.1 its ability to figure out a better series/parallel wiring differs with mine. For power requirements, I still reference my own math over DARDT (except for ATMOS...since I have to appease Dolby...the sheet has to think that everything is good-to-go).

              Comment

              • Jay Wyatt
                Film Handler
                • Jan 2020
                • 45
                • Los Angeles

                #8
                Home runs w/ single-ended amp channels.

                + No guesswork for load balancing. No tradeoffs for damping.
                + Allows gain shading throughout the array. Handy in stadium seating when the distance between seat and speaker becomes shorter further back in the rake.
                + Enables small delays (1-2ms) on the output side which can be helpful for when their is oddities in architecture spanning an array (portwall kickouts, overhangs, entryways).
                + Far easier to troubleshoot and resilient to any individual points of failure at the load end. Many modern amps even have pilot tones or speaker test routines that are not likely to work on a series/parallel network.
                + Future proofed for IAB/Atmos

                -- Will cost more with the needed amp channels. But multichannel amps (8-16+) with respectable output per channel are becoming far more commonplace and footprints are shrinking (1RU).

                Comment

                • Christos Gartaganis
                  Film Handler
                  • Sep 2021
                  • 58
                  • Athens Greece

                  #9
                  I would never consider installing a multichannel amplifier having more than 4 channels per unit. Using an amplifier with 8 or more channels raises the risk of losing multiple audio channels at once if the amplifier's power supply fails, not to mention the inability of driving multiple channels at full power simultaneously.

                  Comment

                  • Jay Wyatt
                    Film Handler
                    • Jan 2020
                    • 45
                    • Los Angeles

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Christos Gartaganis
                    I would never consider installing a multichannel amplifier having more than 4 channels per unit. Using an amplifier with 8 or more channels raises the risk of losing multiple audio channels at once if the amplifier's power supply fails, not to mention the inability of driving multiple channels at full power simultaneously.
                    You'd have an equal risk with a two channel amp running multiple surrounds in a series, parallel, or series/parallel network.

                    Comment

                    • Hong Sung Hyeok
                      Film Handler
                      • Dec 2020
                      • 61
                      • Seoul, South KOREA

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Marco Giustini
                      @Hong Sung Hyeok

                      The sheet is quite nice - it's impressive what AI can do with HTML these days.

                      I didn't look into that too carefully but some time ago (before AI existed!) I did my own excel sheet to calculate 7.1 power calculation. Dolby then added the same feature on their Atmos calculator so I stopped updating mine.

                      Considering the Atmos calculator is quite a powerful tool and also contains 5.1 and 7.1, I wonder whether that should be the one to use? Keeping track of all the speaker data is not easy and I'd imagine Dolby are in a better position to get accurate data from the manufacturers.

                      I'm not saying your hard work is not useful, just that the some of the features seem to be already available on the Dolby one. Thoughts?

                      Yes... I asked an acquaintance to check the document I had created, and He told me about the existence of the "dardt" Excel file.
                      I only found out about it after I had already made my post.

                      It reminded me of the saying, "There is a very high probability that any idea I come up with already exists in the world." Hahaha.
                      It would be hard to surpass Dolby's immense wealth of information, wouldn't it

                      One downside of the dardt document seems to be that it cannot calculate the complex wiring configurations—such as multiple, series, or parallel connections—used for surround speakers in standard movie theaters.

                      I gained a lot of knowledge myself while grappling with the AI. I’d like to believe that my efforts held at least a little bit of value.

                      Right now, I’ve installed FreeCAD mcp and am wrestling with ChatGPT; I’ve fed it the schematics and manuals and asked it to design a 3D-printable board case—modeled after a card cage—to house some BARCO boards that were salvaged from a DLP and are currently just lying around.

                      The progress of AI is truly remarkable; I’m amazed by it every day.

                      Comment

                      • Christos Gartaganis
                        Film Handler
                        • Sep 2021
                        • 58
                        • Athens Greece

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Jay Wyatt

                        You'd have an equal risk with a two channel amp running multiple surrounds in a series, parallel, or series/parallel network.
                        This is true. However it is much easier to instantly replace a standard 2-channel amplifier with a backup unit sitting around your warehouse from a previous installation. Sourcing a dedicated multichannel amplifier for quick replacement is not always feasible.

                        Comment

                        • Marco Giustini
                          Film God
                          • Jan 2020
                          • 1191
                          • Reading, UK

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Hong Sung Hyeok


                          Yes... I asked an acquaintance to check the document I had created, and He told me about the existence of the "dardt" Excel file.
                          I only found out about it after I had already made my post.

                          It reminded me of the saying, "There is a very high probability that any idea I come up with already exists in the world." Hahaha.
                          It would be hard to surpass Dolby's immense wealth of information, wouldn't it
                          Your work is great, don't feel discouraged. As Steve mentioned, maybe you can focus on implementing what is missing from the DARDT

                          The excel sheet I made was aimed at 5.1 and 7.1 when the DARDT didn't have that section. I then found that keeping it up to date with the speakers data and everything else was not a trivial task and eventually Dolby added 5.1/7.1 in DARDT so I stopped working on it.

                          Comment

                          • Steve Guttag
                            Film God
                            • Jan 2020
                            • 3825
                            • Annapolis, MD

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Christos Gartaganis

                            This is true. However it is much easier to instantly replace a standard 2-channel amplifier with a backup unit sitting around your warehouse from a previous installation. Sourcing a dedicated multichannel amplifier for quick replacement is not always feasible.
                            It seems like you are creating a selective argument. That is, if you sold more 8 channel amps, you'd be more likely to have those amps, as well.

                            In general, except for Atmos and 4-way speakers, I stick to 4-channels or less too. A typical 7.1 system, for me is a 4-channel on Left/Right, 4-channel on Center/Sub, 4-channel on surrounds.

                            When doing ATMOS...it's all 8-channel for me. I build in a spare for Center (since I'm going to have an odd number of screen channels anyway) and on the surrounds, I interleave the rows so if an amplifier fails, you will lose an alternate pair of rows not two rows that are adjacent (think of a row as a Left Side, Top Left, Top Right, Right Side). It minimizes the "pain" of a failed amp. With Q-SYS, I build in bypassing around screen channels that may have failed due to speaker or amp...and, again, Center is 100% backed up.

                            Now, I HAVE used the Dolby DMA when I couldn't source my first pick. So, 32-channels on one and 24-channels on the other.

                            image.png

                            Guess at how many intake fans there are. Over 50-channels of amplifier in that rack and there is STILL room for more stuff. Note, the video monitor and multi-source switching. That rack was going to have a collection of 8-channel amps for the surrounds. Knock on wood, its been 4+ years on line and we haven't lost either of the DMA amps. We do power them down nightly though.

                            As to one amp channel per speaker for a typical 7.1 system, while certainly ideal, the added cost is substantial for zero increase ticket sales or even perceived improvement in performance. In order to take advantage of multiple sound levels/delays you'd need a suitable processor to handle that too...which again, is jacking up the price of things. I think the OV2 tops out at 16-channels (but I'm sure Mike Babb will provide the details soon enough)...with 6-12 of them being consumed in speaker crossovers, you are going to run out of channels there to have dedicated DSP on EACH surround speaker. Then there is full blown DSP, like Q-SYS where you can absolutely have dedicated tuning, level balancing, time-delay matching...whatever. As most know, I use Q-SYS as my 1st-choice on most systems but rarely do I allocate that many channels to the surrounds. There are a couple of rooms where yes, do to odd shapes, particularly on the rear wall, that breaking it up into multiple zones, you can have it present like a uniform flat wall, from the patron's perspective.

                            Parallel wiring, bringing this back to the OT just isn't all that hard to do...even some basic series-parallel isn't all that hard and it doesn't raise the cost so much. I'd rather the money go into the right amount os speakers and quality of speaker than into more amplifier channels.

                            Comment

                            Working...