BluRay into CP750 common practice?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ryan Gallagher
    Film God
    • Nov 2022
    • 2912
    • Austin, Texas, USA

    #1

    BluRay into CP750 common practice?

    In our smaller room I've never operated with regularity, but am now due to big room being closed.

    We have a blu-ray hooked up to both 1xAES digital 3, and 1xSPDIF digital 4.

    Those who configured and labeled it made digital 3 as "BR 5.1", and digital 4 as "BR 2.0".

    However, the way the 750 is configured. Digital 3 is set to force "ProLogic II" on both PCM and Dolby Digital. Digital 4 was set to PCM "None" and Dolby Digital "Auto" (which only guarantees a 2.0 playback if you are not sending bitstream data from the player).

    Given that many if not most blu-rays are in fact DTS-HD MA as their primary discrete format. What is the proper procedure to at least get compressed Dolby 5.1 into the room? It's an Oppo player, I can set the output to LPCM or bitstream. I lose audio as we were configured when I choose bitstream with a DTS-HD bluray as the CP750 can't handle that bitstream. It was previously configured to output LCPM in the Oppo. So I expect all blu-ray's played in this room were playing stereo LPCM and letting ProLogic do the expansion in the CP750?

    The proper way feels like bitstream in the player, but use the player menus to select the alternate "fall back" dolby 5.1 version that can be transmitted and decoded via the "auto" setting in the CP750.

    Or if you get crazy you could add a HDMI to AES type device and actually switch between DCP and BluRay on your primary discrete input on the CP750?

    Just feels like we were very much in compromise territory as previously configured. Unless operators knew to switch things. But the labels indicate this was intentional.
  • Benjamin Ruder
    Film Handler
    • Jan 2020
    • 52
    • Chicago, IL

    #2
    I have a CP650 but run a lot of BR for courses and during a recent upgrade added a Vanity Pro to handle the multichannel decoding so we can now seamlessly perform DTS or Dolby off of the discs. Not really applicable to your situation, but I do understand the frustration. Previously the Dolby required an OPPO output change and a different input selection on CP650 so I never had the students run it this way and everyone got Pro-Logic. :/

    Comment

    • Marco Giustini
      Film God
      • Jan 2020
      • 1191
      • Reading, UK

      #3
      At work we've been through "cheap" options for that issue so many times. None worked reliably.

      Options which worked:
      - A BD player with 7.1 analogue outputs
      - An AP20/AP25

      Yes, the second option is overkilled but in the end cheaper than some crazy Pro AV stuff. And it works well!

      All I can say is: avoid those cheap "DTS to analogue" adaptors you find online. At least a few years ago, they were just trash.
      BTW that was a while ago, not sure if there is something new nowadays which can work and decode DTS for you.

      You can also get an AVR with 7.1 analogue outputs. Some can be bad as they might get the outputs from the AMPLIFIED outs - so you get distortion for free. Proper AVR Pre-Amps are considered "High-End" and end up costing an arm and a leg. Plus it's incredibly easy to mess them up

      On a side note, are BD still primarily DTS-MA? Since Atmos became more common, Dolby True-HD became more popular as if you have an Atmos track, you also have Dolby True-HD.

      Comment

      • Ryan Gallagher
        Film God
        • Nov 2022
        • 2912
        • Austin, Texas, USA

        #4
        Originally posted by Marco Giustini
        At work we've been through "cheap" options for that issue so many times. None worked reliably.

        Options which worked:
        - A BD player with 7.1 analogue outputs
        - An AP20/AP25

        Yes, the second option is overkilled but in the end cheaper than some crazy Pro AV stuff. And it works well!

        All I can say is: avoid those cheap "DTS to analogue" adaptors you find online. At least a few years ago, they were just trash.
        BTW that was a while ago, not sure if there is something new nowadays which can work and decode DTS for you.

        You can also get an AVR with 7.1 analogue outputs. Some can be bad as they might get the outputs from the AMPLIFIED outs - so you get distortion for free. Proper AVR Pre-Amps are considered "High-End" and end up costing an arm and a leg. Plus it's incredibly easy to mess them up

        On a side note, are BD still primarily DTS-MA? Since Atmos became more common, Dolby True-HD became more popular as if you have an Atmos track, you also have Dolby True-HD.
        Our big room was an AP20, so it was a no brainer over there.

        I can't speak for all commercial discs, but at least when dealing with the non-UHD ones (we are still a 2K room), ATMOS/TrueHD is a little less common. Well for us anyway, we are usually deep in the back catalogs being a classics/rep art-house. It would not surprise me at all if ATMOS/TrueHD was far more common on contemporary releases, even 1080p ones.

        The AudioPraise VanityPro unit ben mentioned looks like a nice bit of kit, although based on the sites I'm seeing it marketed on, probably comes with a rather heavy "audiophile" markup. Can't find a price, and back-ordered. But doesn't matter, we are still in pre-demolition mode over here (yes the small theatre gets rebuilt "soon", aka 1 to infinity years), and no real money is going to be thrown at something like this that has been "fine" for eons, as nice as such options would be.

        We are probably in the operator menus juggle game if we want to force a screening with true 5.1 for now (best we can get being the lossy compressed version). But definitely open to learning all the better ways to do it.

        It also seems to be yet another reason to prefer ripping discs to DCP. The discrete DTS-HD version comes over that way.

        Comment

        • Marco Giustini
          Film God
          • Jan 2020
          • 1191
          • Reading, UK

          #5
          This is a review and measurements of the Audiopraise VanityPro HDMI audio extractor. It was kindly sent to me by their distributor, JVB Digital and costs US $1,599. The VanityPro is a compact device, not much bigger than typical desktop audio products. Its main functionality is to extract...


          $1600 apparently.

          If that is within your budget, it looks like a good product. Just avoid $50 from Ebay/Aliexpress, they just waste your time.

          Comment

          • Ryan Gallagher
            Film God
            • Nov 2022
            • 2912
            • Austin, Texas, USA

            #6
            Originally posted by Marco Giustini
            https://www.audiosciencereview.com/f...tractor.30440/

            $1600 apparently.

            If that is within your budget, it looks like a good product. Just avoid $50 from Ebay/Aliexpress, they just waste your time.
            Ooof. You can indeed get a used AP20 for less than that (if you are lucky). For a single HDMI input into discrete outputs, that does feel a bit like audiophile pricing. It has a nice display on it apparently at least.

            Considering we have an AP20 sitting in a box that is unlikely to go back into service in the other room (TBD). I guess I have a $0 answer... but a whole room to re-tune if we wanted to go there.

            Comment

            • Benjamin Ruder
              Film Handler
              • Jan 2020
              • 52
              • Chicago, IL

              #7
              Originally posted by Ryan Gallagher

              Ooof. You can indeed get a used AP20 for less than that (if you are lucky). For a single HDMI input into discrete outputs, that does feel a bit like audiophile pricing. It has a nice display on it apparently at least.

              Considering we have an AP20 sitting in a box that is unlikely to go back into service in the other room (TBD). I guess I have a $0 answer... but a whole room to re-tune if we wanted to go there.
              Yeah for our situation with 4 OPPOS and 3 computer inputs it saves a lot of trouble especially as we were upgrading and not wanting to massively reengineer a room for this as we need the CP650 for film. If $1600 was what we paid it was very small cost considering the digital projector, server, and screen all got updated.

              Comment

              • Carsten Kurz
                Film God
                • Jan 2020
                • 1486
                • Germany

                #8
                Unfortunately, even an AP20/25 doesn't solve all issues, as I had to learn recently. I needed to play a few Blurays with DolbyTrueHD tracks - and while I know that the AP20 is not able to decode DolbyTrueHD, it also does NOT fall back to the backup AC3 track - means, no audio. Also, no LPCM. I have a cheap preview monitor dating vom 2009 connected, and it plays the sound without issues.
                Something does not work with the AP20 HDMI audio communication. The only thing that works is configuring the Bluray Player to stereo LPCM and then applying neo6 on the AP20.

                Still looking for a proper (digital) solution. I tried both a Panasonic and a Sony Bluray Player (the Panasonic also offers 8ch analog out). But neither player will output Multichannel LPCM over HDMI.

                I think, though, that an Oppo should offer all necessary options.

                Still love our AP20 for its feature set and solidi operations.

                Comment

                • Marco Giustini
                  Film God
                  • Jan 2020
                  • 1191
                  • Reading, UK

                  #9
                  This is frustrating, the AP20 should decode AC3. And under no circumstances should you be left with no sound.

                  A bit OT but did you try with a different player? HDMI is a jungle as usual...

                  Comment

                  • Steve Guttag
                    Film God
                    • Jan 2020
                    • 3825
                    • Annapolis, MD

                    #10
                    In the Pro world, there is the Extron SSP200 that will decode DTS or Dolby high bit rate (HBR) to analog output and Turtle AV "Downtown" that will output not only analog but also AES67 or Dante (with network redundancy).



                    And, if one has Q-SYS, the DCIO-H will decode up to DTS-HD or Dolby Digital Plus (not Dolby any of the HBR from Dolby, which makes it a problem for some discs).

                    Comment

                    • Marco Giustini
                      Film God
                      • Jan 2020
                      • 1191
                      • Reading, UK

                      #11
                      When you say HBR you mean Dolby True-HD? I thought any lossless format came with a lossy core (AC3 or standard DTS) so you're never left with Stereo or no sound?

                      Comment

                      • Ryan Gallagher
                        Film God
                        • Nov 2022
                        • 2912
                        • Austin, Texas, USA

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Steve Guttag
                        In the Pro world, there is the Extron SSP200 that will decode DTS or Dolby high bit rate (HBR) to analog output and Turtle AV "Downtown" that will output not only analog but also AES67 or Dante (with network redundancy).



                        And, if one has Q-SYS, the DCIO-H will decode up to DTS-HD or Dolby Digital Plus (not Dolby any of the HBR from Dolby, which makes it a problem for some discs).
                        Cool, I was wondering how this gets handled in QSYS, as at least one of our rooms is likely headed that direction after renovation completes.

                        Comment

                        • Ryan Gallagher
                          Film God
                          • Nov 2022
                          • 2912
                          • Austin, Texas, USA

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Carsten Kurz
                          Unfortunately, even an AP20/25 doesn't solve all issues, as I had to learn recently. I needed to play a few Blurays with DolbyTrueHD tracks - and while I know that the AP20 is not able to decode DolbyTrueHD, it also does NOT fall back to the backup AC3 track - means, no audio. Also, no LPCM. I have a cheap preview monitor dating vom 2009 connected, and it plays the sound without issues.
                          Something does not work with the AP20 HDMI audio communication. The only thing that works is configuring the Bluray Player to stereo LPCM and then applying neo6 on the AP20.

                          Still looking for a proper (digital) solution. I tried both a Panasonic and a Sony Bluray Player (the Panasonic also offers 8ch analog out). But neither player will output Multichannel LPCM over HDMI.

                          I think, though, that an Oppo should offer all necessary options.

                          Still love our AP20 for its feature set and solidi operations.
                          Wow, I must have never run into any of these problematic DolbyTrueHD discs... we have quite the blu-ray library too. Our Oppo + AP20 handled everything I could put in there.

                          Comment

                          • Carsten Kurz
                            Film God
                            • Jan 2020
                            • 1486
                            • Germany

                            #14
                            This occurred only recently with two Disney BRs. Im most cases, the BRs in Germany contain HD-Master tracks. Sometimes explicit additional 'classic' DTS or AC3 tracks. I have no idea why this happens recently with these discs. The AP20 should force a fallback to AC3 in these cases. These two players are only connected to the AP20, no splitter or any other HDMI gear in-between. I need to find to time to check this with other discs.

                            Comment

                            • Stefan Scholz
                              Pro Film Handler
                              • Jan 2020
                              • 301
                              • Berlin Germany

                              #15
                              Remember, the APO 20/ AP 25 concept dates bach to the times of DTS, and that is 20years now.
                              Even 15 years since 2010, when I did the first ones, is stone age in Home technology! HDMI 1.4 switching will not transfer 4K signals, not support all codecs.
                              And being DTS, the Dolby decoding capabilities, present on the home cinema model, are software castrated in the theatrical lowest price box. The home box with polished sides easily cost 6 to 10 depending on seller.
                              I always doubted the need to screen BluRay in theatres, unless t is a rural film club society in their barn cinema doing local art work. And these normally use current Home theatre gear, including Atmos home.

                              Also most better BD players can be sound via multichannel PCM enabled, and all IMB solutions used, except the very first ones, offer PCM passthrough from the HDMI in to the AES out. So normally I am fine with a BD connected to the HDMI in of the IMB. Not the projector HDMI/ DP/ SDI ports. And use a "live playlist" option to screen BD via IMB. So the need for audio decoding in the AP 20 vanished, compared to 2010s.

                              I personally convert home sources from BD to be screened into a DCP package. (Does not really take too long, 2K around 150 fps is like 1/2 hour on a medium powered desktop computer.)
                              Why bother with the lack of reliability of disc playout at all?

                              Comment

                              Working...